Maybe Right-Wing SCOTUS Justices Just Need To Try Harder
A radically simple suggestion for fixing American democracy
A former clerk for Supreme Court Chief Justice John Roberts has a modest suggestion for how to fix an institution widely viewed by the American public as corrupt and increasingly illegitimate.
This suggestion, offered by University of Chicago law professor William Baude, is radical in its simplicity. The libs simply won't be able to wrap their heads around such a common-sense solution to a vexing problem of national importance.
"The best Supreme Court reform," Baude wrote this week in The New York Times, "would just be for the justices to try harder and do a better job."
You're reeling, I know. I am too. The room began to spin when I read these words of hardened wisdom. Everything had changed in one sentence. Our democracy has been healed.
Never in all my blogging about bringing the nation's high court in line with constitutional rule of law had I considered – even for a fleeting moment – to ask the Court's bad-faith, right-wing majority to buck up and try harder and to do a better job interpreting the laws of the United States. I had never once considered the power of asking nicely for Clarence Thomas – who lives to own the libs – and Samuel Alito – fighting his own holy war from the bench – and Neil Gorsuch and Brett Kavanaugh and Amy Coney-Barrett and of course Roberts himself to stop what they're doing and "try harder."

And honestly, that's on me. As an American citizen and blogger concerned about the right wing's capture of the Supreme Court and the absence of political will to fix the Roberts Court, I should have realized that an honest, earnest request for greater effort was all it took to fix a high court engaged in near-constant warfare with the rest of the federal judiciary.
Beyond the comedic levels of gaslighting that animate Baude's borderline satirical NYT column, there's this: Republican appointees on the Supreme Court are trying quite hard in their efforts to unwind the civil rights gains of the 20th century, an effort Thurgood Marshall saw clearly in the late 80s and early 90s as the conservative judicial project picked up steam and prepared for a decades-long revenge tour against the liberals who have successfully – if slowly – expanded basic constitutional rights to marginalized parts of American society.
Alito and Thomas and and Roberts and the rest to maximum effort into the push to kill abortion rights (bodily autonomy) and government policy that helps people of color access education and policies that protect LGBTQ folks. Roberts tried very hard to get certain cases in front of the Court's right-wing supermajority so they could beat progress to death in front of those who had fought so hard with so much good faith and decency to advance freedom and fairness for all.

Using the grotesque and anti-democracy concept of a Major Questions Doctrine and weaponizing constitutional originalism – the font from which all bad faith flows – Roberts and his colleagues have made every effort possible to advance a horrifying vision of the United States, one in which the opposition has no claim to power and the president – certain presidents, anyway – stand above the law like a leviathan.
The Court's right-wing jurists have tried very hard to play the bad-faith game in which white people – particularly white men – are the real aggrieved minority in the United States, in need of support and protection from a government that has made life too good for Black and brown folks in the country. Most recently Roberts and company said (in bad faith) that the advancement of people of color over the past half century means Republican-controlled state legislatures can go back to Jim Crow-style electoral maps. This court, captured by the oligarchy and coordinating with a radical anti-democracy movement, has, in fact, tried as hard as they can to achieve the aims of their paymasters, golf buddies, and cocktail party hosts.

So no, William Baude, it is not lack of effort that's stopping the U.S. Supreme Court from earning the approval of the American public. That's not it at all. I would prefer they stop trying so damn hard to envelope every aspect of American society with their constant legislating from the bench.
What you can see here – what you should see – is real, festering fear that a new crop of Democratic lawmakers who have lived through a decade of competitive authoritarianism is not here to make tweaks around the edges of a system that can't properly function without a legitimate, law-abiding, good-faith high court. They are here to fuck shit up, to neutralize Roberts' slow-motion massacre of the constitutional order, and to reverse the monstrous laws and policies SCOTUS has happily and greedily green-lighted during the Trump years.
Baude and Roberts and Alito – who once again is whining about potential SCOTUS reforms – know what's coming. They know their whole wretched game is over if they lose the Supreme Court, which is why they must.


