Do The Propaganda
Like everything else in consumerist society, democracy must be sold.
It's a familiar dance for those of us who are terminally online. It's sometimes clumsy and stupid and makes you squirm a bit because maybe you think to yourself: They do that, not us.
The dance is propaganda, and it's what western democracies have to embrace if they are going to survive the algorithmically-powered advance of fascism in every republic on earth in this third decade of the 21st Century. If you, like me, see politics as an exercise in telling people how they should perceive the world – and more importantly, how they should perceive right and wrong – then you're going to need a flood of videos and articles and books and movies and every other kind of content dedicated to telling folks that multiracial constitutional democracy is actually good and anything or anyone who threatens it is actually bad.
Like everything else in a hopelessly consumerist society, democracy must be sold.
Support the reader-backed Bad Faith Times and join the Bad Faith Times discord channel. You can also subscribe for free.
I wrote this week for Liberal Currents about liberals' apparent discomfort with even the most modest kinds of propaganda. The Democratic National Committee last year launched a social media account of various social sites designed to spread anti-Republican clips to the masses without explicitly identifying as the Democratic Party (even though, as I mentioned in the Liberal Currents piece, the social media bio of this account, FactPostNews, says it is operated by the DNC).

This libbed-out account is not spreading anything particularly untruthful. Propaganda, as 20th Century fascist movements understood, has to be as truthful as possible if it's going to be effective. FactPostNews is doing what good propaganda does: Highlighting your opponents' flaws and mistakes and gaffes, portraying them as unceasingly wrong and bad and ill-willed, and constructing that with your side as correct and good and decent.
That might feel gross for a lot of well-meaning liberals. People, you might think, should just know what is good and what is bad. They should not require an algorithm full of carefully-edited videos to tell them these things. But as NYU media studies and communications professor Daniel Gilmore told me:
"I understand why some people find that to be a bit distasteful, but it very much feels like a ‘don't hate the player, hate the game’ situation. This is the media landscape that politics exists in currently. Democrats didn't invent that. They can either skate to where the puck is on reaching voters or they can cede that landscape to Republicans, which, inadvertently is basically what happened from the mid 2010s through 2024."
There was a fair amount of praise for this DNC propaganda campaign among Bluesky posters who have desperately wanted Democrats to act a little more like Republicans during the authoritarian onslaught of the past decade. There was also some reticence, and more than a little criticism of the DNC social media propaganda effort. The thinking among those opposed to the campaign seemed to go something like this: Political parties should win the right way or not at all. There should be no trickery. There should only be good-faith earnestness in how the Democratic Party communicates with its base – folks who would self immolate before casting a single vote for a Republican candidate – and with those who flip flop between the two major parties depending on the price of eggs and milk and gas and whatnot.

Pro-democracy propaganda should not, of course, be exclusive to promoting the Democratic Party. That, I think, should go without saying. Real and effective pro-democracy propaganda would promote respect and dignity for all people, for women, for LGBTQ folks, for people of color, for migrants, for the workers, for the working poor, for the non-working poor. For everyone. This propaganda would say in ways both subtle and obtuse: You are worthy of a decent life no matter who you are or what you do. You are valuable because you exist.
You see some of that propaganda today with the underlying messages worked into the long-awaited GTA VI, which tells the young men playing the game that they can and should treat women as fully human, to be nice, to be generous. Imagine that.
Follow Denny Carter on Bluesky at @dennycarter.bsky.social.

